Green Supply Chain CITI

Corporate Climate Action CATI

  • CITI score

    16.96

    Total Possible Score: 100
  • Total rank

    78

    Out of 650 total brands
  • Industry rank

    4

    Out of 32 total brands in the Household and Personal Care industry
  • CATI score

    44.80

    Total Possible Score: 100
  • Total rank

    40

    Out of 1000 total brands
  • Industry rank

    2

    Out of 33 total brands in the Household and Personal Care industry

CITI Category Scores Analysis

CATI Category Scores Analysis

CITI Category Scores Benchmarking

CATI Category Scores Benchmarking

CITI Category Scores

CATI Category Scores

1.  Responsiveness and Transparency(total score: 14.00)

1.00
  • 1.1 Respond to Enquiries and Engage with Public
    1.00

    Brand publicly commits to carrying out green supply chain management, OR Brand responds to public inquiries about green supply chain management.

  • 1.2 Promote Supply Chain Transparency
    0.00

    Brand has not disclosed a list of its suppliers in China.

2.  Compliance and Corrective Actions(total score: 18.00)

1.00
  • 2.1 Establish Screening Mechanism
    0.00

    Brand has not begun to screen its suppliers’ environmental compliance.

  • 2.2 Push Suppliers to Take Corrective Actions
    1.00

    Brand publicly requires supplier environmental compliance in writing, such as in their Supplier Code of Conduct, and commits to stakeholders that it will push suppliers to adopt corrective actions.

3.  Extend Green Supply Chain Practices(total score: 30.00)

3.00
  • 3.1 Responsible management of chemicals
    1.00

    Brand extends its environmental management to chemical production, use and discharge along its supply chain, and publicly discloses matching requirements.

  • 3.2.1* Responsible management of wastewater
    1.20

    Brand extends its environmental management to wastewater generation, treatment and discharge along its supply chain, and publicly discloses matching requirements.

  • 3.2.2* Responsible management of solid waste
    0.80

    Brand extends its environmental management to solid waste transportation, utilization and disposal along its supply chain, and publicly discloses matching requirements.

  • 3.3 Responsible management of logistic supplier
    0.00

    Brand has not yet publicly disclosed its green logistics requirement.

  • 3.4 Supplier self-management
    0.00

    Brand has not yet taken action to push its suppliers to control environmental risks along their own supply chains.

4.  Energy Conservation and Emissions Reduction(total score: 32.00)

10.96
  • 4.1 Push suppliers to reduce their energy use and carbon footprint, and disclose energy and climate data
    8.96

    Brand calculates the greenhouse gas emissions from its value chain, publicly discloses its value chain reduction targets and implement initiatives to reduce greenhouse gas emissions across its value chain.

  • 4.2 Push suppliers to reduce resource use and pollutant emissions, and disclose pollutant release and transfer data
    2.00

    Brand has publicly disclosed resource use and efficiency, and pollutant reduction target(s) and the progress made against these targets.

5.  Promote Public Green Choice(total score: 6.00)

1.00
  • 5.1 Guide the public into paying attention to the environmental performance of its supply chains in China
    1.00

    Brand proactively discloses information in annual reports and other public documents, websites, social media platforms or other public channels about its work to improve supply chain environmental performance.

Note:

The total score of category 3.2 is 12, while the conversion ratio for indicator 3.2.1 and 3.2.2 will vary by industry (See CITI Evaluation Guidelines-Appendix II)

1.1  Governance:
Pledged Policies (total score: 5.00)

4.00
  • 1.1.1 Company has committed to climate actions and made climate declaration(s)
    1.00
  • 1.1.2 Company has developed corporate carbon neutrality plan and management system
    1.00
  • 1.1.3 Company has incorporated supplier carbon data reporting into supplier code of conduct
    1.00
  • 1.1.4 Company has developed policies to guide low-carbon production and lifestyle, contributing to the transition towards a low-carbon society
    1.00

1.2  Governance:
Mechanism Construction (total score: 5.00)

3.00
  • 1.2.1 Company has integrated climate-related issues into its business strategy and has specific climate-related risk management procedures
    1.00
  • 1.2.2 Company has integrated climate-related issues into board-level oversight
    1.00
  • 1.2.3 Company employs Blue EcoChain or other automated methods to track supplier climate performance
    0.00
  • 1.2.4 Company offers capacity building and financial incentives, and/or launches innovative projects for suppliers to reduce emissions
    1.00

2.1  Measurement & Disclosure:
Scope 1&2 Emissions (total score: 10.00)

10.00
  • 2.1.1 Company has publicly disclosed Scope 1&2 emission data
    5.00
  • 2.1.2 Company has publicly disclosed carbon intensity
    2.00
  • 2.1.3 Company has publicly disclosed energy efficiency
    2.00
  • 2.1.4 Company has publicly disclosed information on carbon emission trading
    1.00

2.2  Measurement & Disclosure:
Scope 3 Emissions (total score: 7.00)

7.00
  • 2.2.1 Company has publicly disclosed Scope 3 emissions
    4.00
  • 2.2.2 Company collects supplier carbon emission data on a regular basis
    3.00

3.1  Carbon Targets Setting:
Scope 1&2 Targets (total score: 7.00)

6.00
  • 3.1.1 Company has set and publicly disclosed its ongoing Scope 1&2 emission reduction targets
    3.00
  • 3.1.2 Company has set and publicly disclosed its Scope 1&2 carbon neutrality target
    2.00
  • 3.1.3 Company has set and publicly disclosed its renewable energy target
    1.00

3.2  Carbon Targets Setting:
Scope 3 Targets (total score: 7.00)

5.00
  • 3.2.1 Company has set and publicly disclosed its ongoing Scope 3 emission reduction targets
    3.00
  • 3.2.2 Company has set and publicly disclosed its Scope 3 carbon neutrality target
    2.00
  • 3.2.3 Company has set specific objectives on promoting suppliers (at least those in China) to set their own emission reduction targets
    0.00

4.1  Performance against Carbon Targets:
Scope 1&2 Emission Reduction Progress (total score: 8.00)

8.00
  • 4.1.1 Company has publicly disclosed progress made against its Scope 1&2 emission reduction targets
    3.00
  • 4.1.2 Company has publicly disclosed progress made against its Scope 1&2 carbon neutrality target
    3.00
  • 4.1.3 Company has publicly disclosed progress made against its renewable energy target
    2.00

4.2  Performance against Carbon Targets:
Scope 3 Emission Reduction Progress (total score: 9.00)

0.00
  • 4.2.1 Company has publicly disclosed progress made against its Scope 3 emission reduction targets
    0.00
  • 4.2.2 Company has publicly disclosed progress made against its Scope 3 carbon neutrality target
    0.00
  • 4.2.3 Company employs Blue EcoChain or other automated methods to track its suppliers’ target setting progress
    0.00

5.1  Climate Action:
Decarbonization in Company Operation (total score: 12.00)

4.00
  • 5.1.1 Company has conducted non-fossil energy utilization projects and/or green power procurement and disclosed associated emission reductions
    2.00
  • 5.1.2 Company has conducted energy efficiency improvement projects and disclosed associated emission reductions
    0.00
  • 5.1.3 Company has conducted energy monitoring and energy management (e.g. energy management system certification)
    1.00
  • 5.1.4 Company has reduced emissions through carbon offsets, and disclosed associated emission reductions (e.g. Carbon Capture, Utilization and Storage (CCUS), Nature-based Solutions (NbS), market-based carbon offset mechanisms)
    1.00
  • 5.1.5 Company has conducted other types of emission reduction projects and disclosed associated emission reductions (e.g. direct emission reduction from manufacturing process, logistic optimization)
    0.00

5.2  Climate Action:
Decarbonization in Value Chain (total score: 6.00)

2.00
  • 5.2.1 Company promotes suppliers to conduct corporate greenhouse gas and energy management (e.g. greenhouse gas accounting, product carbon footprint certification, energy management system certification)
    1.00
  • 5.2.2 Company has launched emission reduction initiatives with suppliers and disclosed associated emission reductions
    0.00
  • 5.2.3 Company has published best practices on supply chain carbon management annually
    0.00
  • 5.2.4 Company has conducted emission reduction projects targeting other emission sources along the value chain and disclosed associated emission reductions
    1.00

5.3  Climate Action:
Affiliated Company Engagement (total score: 8.00)

0.00
  • 5.3.1 Affiliates have measured and publicly disclosed their carbon emission at facility level
    0.00
  • 5.3.2 Affiliates have set carbon targets, tracked and public disclosed reduction progress at facility level
    0.00

5.4  Climate Action:
Upstream Supplier Engagement (total score: 16.00)

1.00
  • 5.4.1 Direct suppliers have measured and publicly disclosed their carbon emissions at facility level
    0.50
  • 5.4.2 Direct suppliers have set carbon targets, tracked and publicly disclosed reduction progress at facility level
    0.50
  • 5.4.3 Indirect suppliers have measured and publicly disclosed their carbon emissions at facility level
    0.00
  • 5.4.4 Indirect suppliers have set carbon targets, tracked and publicly disclosed reduction progress at facility level
    0.00
  • 5.4.5 Company employs Blue EcoChain or other automated methods to empower upstream suppliers on supply chain carbon management
    0.00
Note:

As carbon hotspots vary from industry to industry, a weighting factor applies across four of the five CATI activity areas: Measurement & Disclosure (17%), Carbon Targets Setting (14%), Performance against Carbon Targets(17%) and Climate Action (42%). The default weighting factors for each industry are shown in the CATI Evaluation Guidelines.

Communication Updates

  • required packaging factory to conduct an audit for its air emissions supervision record(s).
    This factory, through motivation from its stakeholder L'Oréal, actively communicated with environmental groups to implement corrective actions for its supervision record(s) from the year(s) 2016, 2021, and underwent a third-party audit to verify the effectiveness of its corrective actions.
    Suzhou
     Air Emissions
    ● Environmental violation issue: Industrial emissions pollution;
    ● Potential impact on: air quality, public health.
     Audit
    ● Rectification progress:Enterprise with violations complete the relevant GCA third-party audits to verify the completion and effectiveness of its corrective actions;
    ●Driving force: Stakeholders and environmentally conscious consumers.
    Publication Date:2022/8/2 18:01:04
  • required factory to issue an explanation for supervision record(s).
    This factory, through motivation from its stakeholder L'Oréal, actively communicated with environmental groups to issue an explanation for its supervision record(s).
    Jiaxing
     Explanation
    ● Rectification progress: Enterprise with violations issue a public explanation;
    ● Driving force: Stakeholders and environmentally conscious consumers.
    Publication Date:2021/3/19 13:09:37
  • required chemical plant to conduct an audit for its wastewater supervision record(s).
    This factory, through motivation from its stakeholder L'Oréal, actively communicated with environmental groups to implement corrective actions for its supervision record(s) from the year(s) 2015, and underwent a third-party audit to verify the effectiveness of its corrective actions.
    Ma'anshan
     Wastewater
    ● Environmental violation issue: Industrial wastewater pollution;
    ● Potential impact on: water quality, river ecology, public health.
     Audit
    ● Rectification progress:Enterprise with violations complete the relevant GCA third-party audits to verify the completion and effectiveness of its corrective actions;
    ●Driving force: Stakeholders and environmentally conscious consumers.
    Publication Date:2019/9/16 16:42:13
x